An update on how my current collaborative venture with Zoe Fothergill is going. We’ve set a date for the kitchen lecture too, the 2nd of March, so we’re heading into the final straits. This post below charts where we found ourselves just after the new year:
Given that Zoe and I met first of all at a ‘pub’ quiz at a previous Project !!Wakaka! event, it seemed that a reasonable next step forwards in our Structure/Content discussion might be to set ourselves a quiz of our own devising. The aim was to clarify our understanding what we meant by the words ‘form’ and ‘structure’ so that we could proceed clearly to the fun bit.
I put together the following questions in response to Zoe’s and my initial discussion, fuelled by a thirst to know what we were talking about when we talked about form (as Raymond Carver’s story collection might less-memorably have been called).
I sent Zoe the questions and asked her if she would agree to us completing our own shortish responses and then sharing them with each other at an agreed time, so that neither of us would be responding to the other’s answers or assumptions. I also asked if she would like to add any questions to the list before we proceeded. The list of questions below is the final set we responded to, complete with questioning annotations.
Feel free to contribute your own answers in the comments!
Quiz on Structure and Form
Can you give some examples of structures in art? (just visual or literary, dance, music etc too?)
List some interesting structures outwith the arts
Is structure a fixed thing?
What is your definition of structure and form?
Which is sturdier, form or structure?
How is poetry structured?
Can you give some examples of form in art?
Can you give some examples of form in poetry?
Which might change more in the making of a piece: form or structure?
What would you understand a ‘structuring device’ to mean?
Is there an artform in which it doesn’t make sense to talk about structure?
Is there an artform in which it doesn’t make sense to talk about form?
Which is most visible to a viewer/reader in a finished piece: form or structure.
Can you think of a song that has either the words ‘structure’ or ‘form’ in its lyrics ?(bonus points for finding a song which has both)
Can you think of any artworks with the words ‘structure’ or ‘form’ in its title? (ditto)
What’s the most formally successful work you’ve ever done? also ever encountered?
Complete the following sentence: The main difference between structure and form is …………………………………………………..
How do you approach making a new piece? (i prefer work to piece – do you mind if we change it? i have jam sandwiches in my head with piece)
Can a piece have no structure?
Can a piece have no form?
Can a work have no content?
Can a work have no meaning?
If form follows function, what does structure follow? (love this question!)
If the medium is the message, can the structure be the content?
When does structure become stricture?
Can the whole of the definition of ‘structure’ be covered by the bigger, more various definitions of the word ‘form’?
Explain what it means to say that structure becomes the content?
What is your favourite prefix to -structure and to -form?
How does the revelation of structure influence meaning?
Without rules and structure what can be assessed?
Is structure a false place to start?
Do you consider preoccupation with structure to be an avoidance of content?
Why is ‘how’ more interesting than ‘what’ but not as compelling as ‘why’?